The Super Mosher 64 - Our Best Games List (2023 Edition)

Jake and Sam finalize the first edition of the Super Mosher 64, the definitive list of their 64 favorite games, by ranking the finalists and submitting the best games they played in 2023 for consideration. They also break down the Palworld discourse, determine the 2023 year-end prediction winner based on 2023 sales, and review Xbox’s 2023 Developer Direct showcase.

2024 Fantasy Critic Gaming Draft

There are no off-seasons for gamers. Jake and Sam jump right back into another season of elite drafting, underwhelming prospects, and shocking underdogs in their 2024 Fantasy Critic Gaming Draft! Which imaginary publisher has the better lineup? Listen and find out!

2024 Gaming Predictions and Resolutions

There’s so much unknown about gaming in 2024, including the Switch 2, PlayStation’s release slate, what will be competing for Game of the Year, and more. Jake and Sam each share their 10 predictions for the year ahead, with a loser livestream on the line. They also list their 2024 gaming resolutions, discuss the Suicide Squad previews, and break down Jake’s Spider-Man 2 review.

2023 Predictions Recap and Results

2023 has come to a close, which means it’s time to recap our 2023 predictions. Did Nintendo announce the Switch 2? Did we finally see MachineGames’ Indiana Jones? The brothers go through their wild (and sometimes prescient) 2023 predictions and determine who won the year!

The Super Mosher 64 - Building Our Best Games List (Part Two)

Last week, the brothers picked their 64 all-time favorite games. This week, they sort them into Platinum, Gold, Silver, and Bronze tiers in preparation to rank them in 2024! You’ll never guess where BioShock, Call of Duty: Black Ops 2, and Towerfall Ascension end up. The brothers also discuss this week’s huge PlayStation news, including the Insomniac hack, The Last of Us Online’s cancellation, and A24’s Death Stranding movie.

The Super Mosher 64 - Building Our Best Games List (Part One)

The Super Mosher Bros. Show has been missing one thing - a “Best Games of All Time” list. To fix that problem, the brothers are creating “The Super Mosher 64,” a definitive list of their favorite 64 games. In this episode, they build out that list, champion their all-time favorites, remove their beloved deep cuts, and fight about Portal vs. Portal 2.

The Game Awards 2023 Recap and Review

The Game Awards 2023 brought another year of exciting announcements, weird celebrity cameos, and a frustrating lack of awards time. The brothers review the show, tally up their predictions, and share their 10 favorite reveals. To make this week’s news even busier, the brothers also discuss Grand Theft Auto VI’s reveal and Fortnite’s huge week!

The Game Awards 2023 Predictions

Do you need help filling out your Game Awards cheatsheet? Sam and Jake have you covered as they make their predictions for the big winners of the 2023 Game Awards. What wins Game of the Year? What game had the best art direction? What game had the biggest impact? Who knows, but we are here to figure it out.

Game Shopping Memories

Black Friday is right around the corner, so in honor of everyone’s favorite capitalist holiday, the brothers share their favorite game shopping memories, including console purchases, retro game discoveries, gaming gifts, and more.

2023 Year-End Predictions

2023 is almost over, which means it’s time for some last-minute predictions! What will be the top 10 selling games of the year? What will the six GOTY nominees be at The Game Awards? What will get snubbed at The Game Awards? We predict all of that and more! In addition to predictions, we discuss a CRAZY news week, including GTA6 and the announcement of a live-action The Legend of Zelda movie.

Weirdest Licensed Game Bracket - Cartoon Edition

The brothers kick off a new bracket series pitting the all-time weirdest licensed games against each other, and in honor of this week’s launch of Nickelodeon All-Star Brawl 2, they start with cartoon games. Nickelodeon, Cartoon Network, The Simpsons, and more – the list gets weird with fairy tale ripoffs, Tomb Raider parodies, and so many exclamation points!

PlayStation Wellness Check

Marvel’s Spider-Man 2, PlayStation’s blockbuster fall release, is finally out, and it’s a critical and commercial success. That means it’s time to put the stethoscope to Jim Ryan’s retired body and check on the health of PlayStation. Was 2023 a great year for the platform? What does their future look like? We answer all of this and more on our final 2023 wellness check!

Starfield Impressions

Jake spent his birthday week playing several hours of Starfield, his first-ever Bethesda game. Sam interviews him about his first impressions of the game, how it performs as a shooter, space adventure, and RPG, and how it stacks up against other 2023 releases.